The anvil and dye table appear to give different colours to armors for the Muster, and the colors of the Anvil do not match those worn by NPCs around Mistlocke. Could it be changed so that all Mustermen wear the new colour scheme (which is the one given by the Anvil), and that the dye table change to the same colour scheme?
I've bugreported this after a DM mentioned we weren't supposed to have two different colours. For now, the barrel works fine but remember to close it then pick up the item after re-opening it. As for the broken dye table, I've been locking it to avoid this :P.
How To Muster It Up:
1: Place gear on the Anvil to get the Super Special Shoulderpads, and general Muster Look, plus the name Muster - (reforged).
2: Place gear in the Barrel on the right.
3: Close barrel.
4: Pick up gear, which is probably on page three of the barrel. Don't panic and tell a DM the barrel ate your chainshirt. Like I did ;).
Both the anvil and the dye barrel provide the same colors now.